€15M Microsoft Audit Overturned: Multi-Vendor Defence for Global Telecom Provider

print
share

Summary

Microsoft SPLA audit: €15M+ exposure avoided, €3.7M overpayment identified. SUSE audit closed with no penalties. Red Hat €1.5M exposure reduced by 50%. Four-phase compliance and negotiation programme.

Industry: Global Telecommunications & Cloud Services Date: 10th September 2025


Executive Summary

A leading global telecommunications and cloud services provider engaged SAMexpert to support them across four major software licensing and compliance challenges:

  1. Microsoft SPLA Audit Defence

    — External auditor's draft findings suggested more than €15M in exposure. SAMexpert's analysis, rebuttals, and negotiation strategy overturned the claim, demonstrating the client had in fact overpaid by ~€3.7M, positioning them to request future credits.

  2. SPLA Internal Self-Verification

    — Following the Microsoft audit, the client engaged SAMexpert to perform a proactive compliance review. By modelling best- and worst-case licensing positions and driving remediation, SAMexpert confirmed compliance within Microsoft's tolerance (<5%) while strengthening governance and reporting maturity.

  3. SUSE Audit Defence

    — SUSE initiated an aggressive audit with wide data demands. SAMexpert successfully restricted scope, challenged overreaching requests, and aligned reporting to contractual terms. The audit was closed with no penalties, with only a small subscription adjustment (<€5K) for maintenance alignment.

  4. Red Hat Risk Assessment & Negotiation Support

    — A technical assessment revealed ~€1.5M of backdated subscription risk and recurring annual shortfalls. SAMexpert identified optimisation opportunities, educated engineering teams, and guided commercial strategy. Through targeted negotiation, the potential liability was reduced by half, and a sustainable subscription baseline was established.

Collectively, these engagements highlight SAMexpert's ability to deliver cost avoidance, risk reduction, and strengthened licensing governance across multiple vendors.


Client Profile

  • Industry:

    Global Telecommunications & Cloud Services

  • Operations:

    Data centres and managed services across EMEA and North America

  • Engagements:

    Microsoft, SUSE, Red Hat licensing audits and internal reviews


The Scope

Microsoft SPLA Audit Defence

Defend against a vendor-led audit, challenge the Effective Licence Position (ELP), and minimise financial exposure.

SPLA Internal Self-Verification

Conduct a proactive compliance assessment post-audit to confirm alignment and address residual risks.

SUSE Audit Defence

Support during a vendor audit, manage scope, protect sensitive infrastructure data, and minimise commercial impact.

Red Hat Risk Assessment & Negotiation Support

Assess deployment risks, prepare negotiation strategy, and optimise long-term subscription model.


The SAMexpert Approach

Phase 1: Microsoft SPLA Audit Defence

  • Conducted a comprehensive baseline risk assessment, modelling exposure scenarios pre-submission

  • Validated data across thousands of servers

  • Identified miscounts, including decommissioned servers and over-reporting of database cores

  • Reinstated processor-to-core surpluses worth millions

  • Produced detailed rebuttals and a negotiation plan with MDO/LDO thresholds

  • Outcome:

    Flipped the audit result from €15M+ claim to >€3.7M overpayment in the client's favour

Phase 2: SPLA Internal Self-Verification

  • Conducted a mock audit replicating vendor methodology

  • Compared compliance snapshots, showing reduction of risks through remediation

  • Flagged residual issues: evidence capture gaps, inconsistent data from legacy systems

  • Delivered recommendations to strengthen governance and prevent recurrence

  • Outcome:

    Compliance confirmed within 5% tolerance; risks contained and reported

Phase 3: SUSE Audit Defence

  • Scoped audit to relevant regional entities, blocking attempts to extend globally

  • Challenged requests for intrusive data beyond contractual terms

  • Clarified obligations after fixed commitment periods expired

  • Guided communications to ensure only relevant data was provided

  • Outcome:

    Audit signed off with no penalties, only minor subscription alignment (<€5K)

Phase 4: Red Hat Risk Assessment & Negotiation Support

  • Consolidated deployment data from multiple discovery tools

  • Quantified exposure: >€1.5M across shared VMs and dedicated hosts

  • Identified optimisation paths: migration planning, remediation, platform upgrades

  • Educated engineering teams on licensing principles

  • Guided commercial negotiations; precedent indicated 50% forgiveness on backdating

  • Outcome:

    Liability reduced by half; long-term subscription optimised


Results & Financial Impact

Vendor

Challenge

Outcome

Microsoft SPLA

€15M+ exposure claim

Exposure avoided; €3.7M overpayment identified

SPLA Internal

Post-audit verification

Compliance within tolerance (<5%); reporting strengthened

SUSE

Vendor audit

Audit closed cleanly; no penalties beyond nominal adjustment

Red Hat

€1.5M potential exposure

Exposure reduced by 50%; sustainable licensing baseline set


Deliverables

  • Risk assessments and ELP rebuttals (Microsoft, Red Hat)

  • Mock audit reports (SPLA self-verification)

  • Negotiation strategies with MDO/LDO ranges

  • Closure documentation and auditor communications (SUSE, Microsoft)

  • Final remediation and governance recommendations


Long-Term Value

Cost Avoidance

Tens of millions saved in avoided penalties and credits secured.

Risk Mitigation

Multiple vendor audits resolved with no material impact.

Audit Readiness

Governance strengthened, compliance brought under control.

Partnership

Repeat engagements across three major vendors demonstrate deep trust.


Conclusion

Through four high-stakes engagements spanning Microsoft, SUSE, and Red Hat, SAMexpert transformed the client's licensing risk posture. From overturning a €15M audit claim, to confirming internal compliance, to closing a SUSE audit with no penalties, to cutting Red Hat exposure in half — SAMexpert consistently delivered measurable results.

This multi-year partnership illustrates the value of expert audit defence, proactive compliance management, and commercial negotiation in maximising cost avoidance and strengthening enterprise governance.

Table of contents
print
share

Read next

More articles